Home>Articles>Bergenfield mayor files defamation suit against ousted incumbent

Arvin Amatorio, left, and Bergenfield Mayor Norman Schmelz in 2019. New Jersey Globe Photo.

Bergenfield mayor files defamation suit against ousted incumbent

By David Wildstein, February 18 2020 1:12 pm

Bergenfield mayor Arvin Amatorio has filed a defamation lawsuit against the incumbent he unseated last year.

Just days before the general election, Norman Schmelz accused Amatorio of violating the Trafficking Victims Protection Act and practicing law without a license.  He called on Amatorio to withdraw from the race.

According to Amatorio, a press release from Schmelz referred to an unrelated immigration case in a bid to misrepresent his character.

“In the run-up to the November 5th election, I was smeared by my opponent and his team for political purposes. They alleged that “immigrant families have been ruined by Mr. Amatorio’s selfish, wrong, and deliberate misfilings [sic] that served to enrich his own and his client’s pockets”. They further added I was illegally practicing law. These false allegations hurt my personal and professional reputation, and I am taking measures to clear my name.”

Amatorio defeated Schmelz by 317 votes, 53%–47%, in the 2019 general election.

In a court filing, Amatorio’s attorney alleged that Schmelz attempted to “break the link of affection and political appeal between Mr. Amatorio, a successful Filipino immigrant, and Filipino and other minority and immigrant voters in Bergenfield by falsely painting him as an exploiter of immigrants.”

Schmelz was a two-term mayor.  He was the Republican candidate for Bergen County Executive in 2018 and lost to incumbent Jim Tedesco by a 63%-37% margin.

Spread the news:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *