A Superior Court judge has scheduled a Thursday court hearing on a recount request in South Toms River, where Republican Mayor Oscar Cradle holds a one-vote lead over Democratic challenger Gigi Esparza in a borough with a history of extraordinarily close elections and protracted court battles over disputed ballots.
In New Jersey, where there is no automatic recount, even when an election is decided by a single vote, Esparza filed a petition in Ocean County Superior Court on Wednesday seeking a hand recount of ballots cast in the November 3 mayoral election.
“I would prefer to get this done before the end of this week, rather than to have it heard next week while I’m in judicial college,” Superior Court Judge Robert Brenner stated during a virtual court conference Wednesday.
Cradle leads Esparza, 441 to 440, with three write-in votes among the 884 ballots cast. The margin is approximately 0.12 percentage points.
Esparza’s attorney, Adam Steuerman, contends that errors may have occurred in counting or tabulating ballots and raised questions about the three write-in votes, including whether any should have been credited to his client.
The petition also questions whether additional provisional or other ballots were rejected or not counted.
Esparza is seeking a recheck of voting machines used on Election Day and during early voting, a hand recount of mail-in and provisional ballots, and access to election records, including rejected ballots and ballot envelopes.
During Wednesday’s court conference, Laura Benson, an attorney representing the Ocean County Clerk, said her office would not oppose the recount.
“On behalf of the county clerk, we’re not going to object, uh, or have really any response to it,” Benson told Brenner.
An attorney representing the Ocean County Board of Elections said he had not yet consulted with board members and could not say whether the board would take a position on the recount request.
Cradle, who appeared without an attorney, told Brenner that he had received notice of the conference about fifteen minutes before it began and was unfamiliar with the procedures.
He said he intended to retain counsel and expected to identify an attorney by tonight.
When Cradle interrupted the proceeding to take a telephone call, Brenner declined to pause the conference.
“This was assigned to me at 11:00 this morning, and I’m doing my job, sir,” Brenner told the mayor.
The judge also requested confirmation that Ocean County officials had certified the election results, which attorneys expected to occur Wednesday.
The recount application comes after a mayoral contest in which the lead changed hands several times as election officials processed outstanding ballots.
Cradle and Esparza were initially tied at 435 votes apiece before Esparza took the lead, 436-435. Cradle subsequently regained the lead after additional ballots were counted.
South Toms River has been through this before.
In 2020, Republican Councilman Sandford Ross and Democrat George Rutzler finished tied at 772 votes apiece for the second council seat.
A challenge by Democrats led to the rejection of two mail-in ballots cast by elderly voters who had signed the ballots themselves rather than just the envelopes. The decision gave Rutzler a two-vote victory, and he was sworn into office.
Ross went to court, arguing that the voters had not intended to identify themselves or compromise ballot secrecy.
One voter was a World War II veteran in his 90s, while the other was a man in his 80s. Both testified that they had never voted by mail before and believed they were supposed to sign their ballots.
In April 2021, Superior Court Judge Arnold Goldman reinstated the ballots, restoring the tie, removing Rutzler from office, and ordering a special election.
The Ocean County Board of Elections appealed, and the special election was canceled even though some voters had already cast ballots.
A three-judge appellate panel upheld Goldman’s ruling in December 2021, but the litigation delayed the election until March 15, 2022, more than sixteen months after the original contest.
Ross defeated Rutzler, 250-142, in a special election that drew just 16% turnout and cost taxpayers an estimated $80,000.
Four years later, Ross has lost his council seat as Democrats flipped both seats up for election this month.
Democrats Jacqueline Burns and Christina Mertz defeated Ross and Republican Crystal Wurst, reducing the Republican majority on the six-member Borough Council from 6-0 to 4-2.
Burns led the four-candidate field with 463 votes, followed by Mertz with 457. Ross received 408 votes, while Wurst finished fourth with 388. Ross was seeking another term, while Wurst was running for the seat being vacated by Republican Councilman Edward Murray, who did not seek re-election.
Esparza, a former member of the Toms River Regional Board of Education, briefly served as mayor after Gregory Handshy’s death in 2022. She lost her council seat in 2023 and unsuccessfully sought a return to the governing body in 2024. Last year, Esparza was the Democratic nominee for State Assembly in the 10th legislative district, losing to Republican incumbents Paul Kanitra (R-Point Pleasant Beach) and Gregory McGuckin (R-Toms River).
Cradle is seeking a second four-year term as mayor.
South Toms River has become increasingly competitive despite Ocean County’s strong Republican leanings.
Donald Trump carried the borough by six percentage points in 2024, but Democratic Gov. Mikie Sherrill won it by eight points in 2025. Democratic U.S. Sen. Cory Booker carried South Toms River by sixteen points in this year’s election.


