The Democratic wave that swept New Jersey in 2026 reached deep into South Jersey, giving Democrats control of Cumberland County government, bringing them within one seat of a majority on the Atlantic County Board of County Commissioners, and helping Zack Mullock defeat five-term Rep. Jeff Van Drew (R-Dennis) in a congressional district Donald Trump carried by double digits two years ago.
But the wave stopped short of Cape May County, where Republicans swept the countywide races, retained all five commissioner seats, and extended a winning streak that dates back to 2000.
Mullock, the Democratic mayor of Cape May, won the congressional seat by four points, carrying Atlantic and Cumberland counties by double digits. Van Drew still won Cape May County by nine points, though his margin fell from 27 points in 2024.
The results reversed years of Republican gains in South Jersey and raised the stakes for the 2027 legislative elections, when Republicans will defend seats in districts where Democrats demonstrated renewed strength this year.
Atlantic County: Democrats move within one seat of control
Atlantic County Democrats scored their biggest victories in decades, sweeping the sheriff’s and county clerk’s races and capturing three seats on the Board of County Commissioners.
Atlantic County Police Director Sean Riggin defeated Republican Sheriff Joe “Tokyo” O’Donoghue, 48,980 to 42,476, while Lisa Bender, a former Assembly candidate, ousted Republican County Clerk Joseph Giralo, 49,443 to 41,830.
Democrats Jonathan Marcellus and Kyle Gornick defeated Republican at-large commissioners John Risley and June Byrnes, while Richard Healey defeated Republican Andrew Parker in the 3rd Commissioner District.
The victories reduced the Republican majority on the commissioner board from 8-1 to 5-4, putting Democrats within striking distance of winning control next year.
Giralo won his first term in 2021, defeating Egg Harbor City Mayor Lisa Jiampetti by ten points to succeed retiring County Clerk Edward McGettigan. O’Donoghue ousted two-term Democratic Sheriff Eric Scheffler in 2023 by six points.
Risley, a 23-year veteran of county government, had survived close elections before, winning re-election by just 203 votes in 2017 and 381 votes in 2020. Republicans also narrowly retained their majority last year, when Democrat Victoria Dolceamore came within 271 votes of defeating Republican Art Schenker for an at-large seat.
Marcellus, a small-business owner, had previously run for commissioner in the Republican-leaning 4th District. Gornick serves on the Atlantic City Planning Board and works as a policy specialist at the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development. Healey works in human resources.
Assemblyman Anthony Angellozzi (D-Hammonton) said Democrats had spent years waiting for an opportunity to reverse their fortunes.
“After 10 years of tough elections, Atlantic County Democrats were hungry for a win.”
Angellozzi, who won his Assembly seat last year, said he wanted to return the support he had received from local Democrats.
“As a newly elected official, I felt like it was my duty to help these candidates because so many of them helped me.”
He credited the candidates with building the grassroots operations needed to win in a county with a long history of Republican political strength.
“The candidates organized and engaged in grassroots politics, and that was the kind of politics Atlantic County needed,” he said.
The county’s Republican organization traces its political dominance to former Senate President Frank “Hap” Farley, whose powerful political machine controlled much of Atlantic County government for decades.
Micah Rasmussen, director of the Rebovich Institute for New Jersey Politics at Rider University, said the Democratic gains were particularly significant given the county’s political history.
“Even as Atlantic County legislative races have swung back and forth, Republicans have dominated the county commissioner board ever since Atlantic adopted the county executive form of government in 1974.”
“It’s been 20 years since Atlantic Democrats last got within striking distance of a control election, so this resurgence is already a generational event for Atlantic Democrats.”
Democrats also made substantial gains in federal races.
Sen. Cory Booker carried Atlantic County by 15 points, while Mullock defeated Van Drew by 13 points, reversing the Republican congressman’s eight-point victory in the county two years earlier.
That represented a 21-point shift toward Democrats in the congressional race.
Trump carried Atlantic County by three points in 2024, and Republican Jack Ciattarelli won it by 12 points in the 2021 gubernatorial election.
Mullock flipped nine municipalities that Van Drew had carried in 2024: Absecon, Egg Harbor Township, Galloway, Hamilton, Linwood, Margate, Northfield, Somers Point and Ventnor.
The Democratic candidates for sheriff and county clerk also made significant inroads in Republican-leaning communities.
Both Riggin and Bender carried Galloway, Egg Harbor Township, Hamilton, Absecon, Somers Point, Northfield and Ventnor.
Giralo carried Egg Harbor Township by 13 points in 2021, and O’Donoghue won it by seven points in 2023. This year, Bender won by ten points and Riggin by four.
In Galloway, Bender won by 11 points and Riggin by ten.
Although the Democratic countywide candidates carried only ten of Atlantic County’s 23 municipalities, their victories in larger communities and improved margins in traditionally Republican areas were enough to produce decisive wins.
Their success extended well beyond Democratic strongholds such as Atlantic City and Pleasantville.
Rasmussen said the challenge for Democrats will be reproducing those results in 2027, when control of county government will be at stake again.
“Now the question is whether they can get the same combination of blue turnout and red disinterest in 2027 as they did in 2026, which, along with how hard this year’s candidates worked, proved to be insurmountable.”
Next year’s elections will also include the 2nd Legislative District, represented by State Sen. Vincent Polistina and Democratic Assembly members Don Guardian and Maureen Rowan.
Rasmussen suggested the legislative and county executive contests could help Democrats maintain their momentum, but might also give Republicans more incentive to turn out.
“They’ll clearly have strong state legislative and county executive races at the top of the ticket to help, but they also could be stronger motivators for Republicans to turn out than this year’s federal races proved to be.”
“With all the critical races happening in Atlantic County next year, I think it’s going to be one of the most exciting places to watch in the state.”
Cumberland County: Democrats complete their comeback
Cumberland County Democrats completed a three-election comeback, reclaiming control of county government after Republicans seized the Board of County Commissioners in 2022 and swept all three seats up for election in 2023.
Democrats began reversing those losses in 2024, when former Sheriff Robert Austino won a commissioner seat, and made additional gains in 2025. This year, they swept all three commissioner races and reclaimed the sheriff’s office.
Joe Pepitone led the Democratic commissioner ticket with 21,761 votes, followed by Ron Franceschini with 21,543 and LaRae Smith with 21,337.
They defeated Republican incumbents Sandra Taylor, who received 16,727 votes; Art Marchand, with 16,509; and James Sauro, with 16,298.
The Democratic sweep returned the commissioner board to Democratic control.
Austino also reclaimed the sheriff’s office, defeating Republican Michael Donato, 21,218 to 17,493, a margin of 3,725 votes.
It was the third election between the two men in six years. Austino defeated Donato in 2020, but Donato returned three years later and ousted him by 11 points. Austino won a commissioner seat in 2024 before launching his campaign to regain the sheriff’s office.
Democrats also picked up a municipal seat in Commercial Township, where former Committeeman Fletcher Jamison defeated Republican incumbent Ronald Sutton by just four votes, 610 to 606.
The victory gave Democrats another local government pickup in a county where Republicans had made substantial gains during the Trump years.
In 2024, Trump carried Cumberland County by four points, becoming the first Republican presidential candidate to win there since 1988. But a year later, Democratic gubernatorial candidate Mikie Sherrill won Cumberland by five points.
This year, Democrats expanded those gains in federal and county races.
Booker defeated Republican Justin Murphy in Cumberland County, 22,078 to 15,935, winning 56.8% of the vote to Murphy’s 41%.
Mullock defeated Van Drew, 21,876 to 16,559, winning 56.2% to the Republican incumbent’s 42.5%.
The result reversed Van Drew’s eight-point victory in Cumberland in 2024.
Mullock flipped Greenwich, Millville and Vineland while increasing his margins in Bridgeton and Fairfield.
Vineland, Cumberland County’s largest municipality, saw a 26-point swing toward Democrats, with Mullock winning by 24 points after Van Drew carried the city by two points in 2024.
Rasmussen said the Democratic comeback in Cumberland reflected the reversal of Republican gains during the Trump years.
“With the notable exception of the First District’s legislative seats, South Jersey Republicans have now given back virtually everything else they gained during the Trump years, and nowhere is this more evident than control of county government in Cumberland.”
He suggested that Republicans in neighboring counties could face similar challenges next year.
“In fact, Cumberland is the harbinger of what Salem and Atlantic Republicans could be facing in next year’s control elections.”
Democrats also benefited from a substantial advantage in returned mail-in ballots.
Registered Democrats returned 5,795 mail ballots, compared with 2,597 from Republicans, a difference of 3,198. Austino ultimately defeated Donato by 3,725 votes.
Those figures reflect the party registration of voters who returned ballots, rather than their actual votes, but they show the size of the Democratic advantage before Election Day.
Cumberland is part of the 1st Legislative District, represented by State Sen. Mike Testa (R-Vineland), a potential 2029 gubernatorial candidate.
Republicans can rely on their continued strength in Cape May County, which shares the legislative district with Cumberland. But the Democratic gains in Cumberland, particularly in Vineland, could complicate the Republican path to re-election.
Rasmussen also pointed to Vineland’s 2028 mayoral election as another contest that could be affected by the county’s changing political environment.
“Maybe the biggest example of what’s at stake is the November 2028 election for Vineland mayor, which was already going to be significantly complicated by the data center upheaval.”
Cape May County: Republicans survive the wave
Cape May County Republicans survived an election that devastated their party elsewhere in South Jersey, sweeping the countywide races, preserving their 5-0 majority on the Board of County Commissioners, and extending a winning streak that began in 2000.
Hotelier Curtis Bashaw, the Republican nominee for U.S. Senate in 2024, and former North Wildwood Mayor Patrick Rosenello won the two open commissioner seats.
Bashaw received 22,683 votes, and Rosenello received 22,462, defeating Democrats Eric Morey, who received 17,746, and David Temple, who received 16,955.
Republican Sheriff Robert Nolan, who ran unopposed, won another term with 26,234 votes.
No Democrat has won a countywide election in Cape May County since Van Drew, then a Democrat, defeated Republican incumbent Mark Videtto in 2000.
Trump carried Cape May County by 19 points in 2024, and Ciattarelli won it by approximately 17 points in his unsuccessful 2025 gubernatorial campaign.
Cape May County Republican Chairman Mike Donohue said the local results demonstrated the resilience of the county’s Republican organization.
“I’m very proud of what we did.”
“We’re still standing, and I’m proud of that,” Donohue said, referring to Cape May County Republicans.
Donohue attributed the party’s success to its record in county government and its elected officials’ relationships with voters.
“We reduced the tax rate four years in a row.”
He said the county’s Republican elected officials had maintained public support through their approach to local government.
“We have elected officials that engage in good government.”
Although Republican margins declined from previous elections, Donohue said the results were not unprecedented.
“This wasn’t even our lowest margin since 2010.”
But the congressional results showed that Cape May Republicans were not immune to the Democratic wave.
Van Drew carried the county by nine points, down from 27 points in 2024. His margin fell from 14,192 votes two years ago to 3,723 this year.
Mullock, who serves as mayor of Cape May, made significant gains throughout the county, particularly in municipalities where Democrats have historically struggled.
He flipped Woodbine, which Van Drew carried by 12 points in 2024, winning it by 13 points this year.
Mullock also carried Cape May Point by 52 points and West Cape May by 26 points.
In Cape May itself, Mullock defeated Van Drew by 18 points. Van Drew had carried the city by less than one point in 2024 and by five points in 2022.
Rasmussen said the congressional contest was unusual because both candidates came from Cape May County, diminishing the advantage Van Drew had traditionally enjoyed as a local candidate.
“When Ocean and Salem counties are underperforming for Republicans, as they did this year, Cape May is their last chance. Except this time Van Drew and his opponent were both sharing the same home county, and when that’s happened in his 15 elections in the county, they’ve usually split it.”
“In fact, the last time Van Drew carried Cape May County by a smaller margin was in 2018 when he was still a Democrat.”
Rasmussen said Mullock could strengthen his position in future elections by establishing himself as Cape May County’s preferred congressional candidate.
“The key now for Mullock is to become the new home county favorite, so that whenever a Republican from another county runs against him, they’re the outsider, and when someone within the county does, they can only fight him to a draw.”
“If he can do this, he can neutralize one of the Second District’s Republican stronghold counties. To do it, he’ll need to cultivate a strong kinship with Ocean City, which is the county’s biggest trove of Republican votes.”
Rasmussen suggested that coastal issues could provide Mullock with an opportunity to build support in Republican beach communities.
“That’s why fighting for beachfront needs has long been such a no-brainer since Bill Hughes did, because it allows a Democrat like Mullock to make a strong case in every Republican beach town from Barnegat Light to Cape May Point.”
He also pointed to the dramatic reduction in Van Drew’s vote margin.
“Just a bit more on numbers—Van Drew carried Cape May County by 14,192 in 2024, 10,903 in 2022, and 12,728 in 2020,” Rasmussen stated. “In his last state legislative race, he carried it by 10,078. Yet this time, Mullock held him to a 3,723 advantage in the county.”
Donohue acknowledged that national politics had become an increasingly important factor in local elections.
“Nationalization has become pervasive,” he said. “It was a perfect storm.”
He said economic concerns, particularly the cost of everyday necessities, contributed to voter dissatisfaction with Republicans.
“There are two things Americans like, gas and steak, and you’re gonna take it out on someone when you can’t afford it,” Donohue said.
He also questioned why local Republican officials should be held responsible for voters’ dissatisfaction with national politics.
“You can’t punish your mayor because you don’t like the president; that doesn’t make sense,” Donohue said.
The GOP leader predicted that some voters could become disillusioned with newly elected Democrats, particularly if political investigations overshadowed economic concerns.
“There is going to be subpoenas and investigations that don’t help with the cost of groceries,” Donohue said.
Despite the Republican victories, Donohue said his party cannot take its traditional supporters for granted.
“You’ve got to do the work to persuade voters,” he said. “You’ve got to get back on the doors.”
Democrats also had a modest advantage in returned mail-in ballots in Cape May County, with 1,136 more ballots returned by registered Democrats than Republicans.
Although considerably smaller than the Democratic advantages in Atlantic and Cumberland, it showed that the party’s mail-voting strength extended even into one of New Jersey’s most reliably Republican counties.
What the results mean for 2027
The Democratic gains in Atlantic and Cumberland, combined with the congressional results in Cape May, leave South Jersey Republicans facing a considerably different political environment heading into next year’s legislative elections.
Mullock defeated Van Drew by four points districtwide, 138,683 to 131,086, in a district Trump carried by 13 points in 2024.
Van Drew had won re-election by 17 points two years earlier.
The Democrat carried Atlantic and Cumberland counties by 13 points each, while reducing Van Drew’s margin in Cape May from 27 points to nine.
Across the district, Mullock flipped 21 municipalities that Van Drew had carried in 2024, including nine in Atlantic County, three in Cumberland, and Woodbine in Cape May.
Democrats also entered Election Day with a substantial advantage in returned mail ballots.
In Atlantic County, registered Democrats returned 5,622 more ballots than Republicans. The Democratic advantage was 3,198 in Cumberland and 1,136 in Cape May.
Combined, registered Democrats returned 9,956 more mail ballots than Republicans in the three counties.
The results also carry implications for the 1st and 2nd Legislative Districts, where Republicans will face voters next year.
Booker carried the 2nd Legislative District by nearly 20 points, despite its representation by Republican State Sen. Vincent Polistina. He also won the 1st District, represented by Testa.
Republicans still have substantial advantages in parts of South Jersey, particularly Cape May County. But the Democratic victories in Atlantic and Cumberland suggest that some of the political coalitions Republicans assembled during the Trump years have weakened.
Rasmussen cautioned against assuming that this year’s results would automatically carry over into 2027, but said the national political environment could continue to create problems for Republicans.
“We should never generalize, and one election is always one election, but if President Trump does not course correct from this election, then he could continue to be a national drag on Republicans for the next two elections, and if that happens, then the damage in South Jersey will continue to pile up,” he explained.
For Democrats, the challenge will be maintaining the turnout and local organizations that produced this year’s victories. Republicans must rebuild support in communities where their candidates were winning comfortably just two years ago.
Cape May County showed that Republican organizations can still survive a Democratic wave. Atlantic and Cumberland showed how quickly years of Republican gains can disappear. The 2027 elections will determine whether this year’s results were a temporary setback for Republicans or the beginning of a lasting political realignment in South Jersey.
Click HERE to download.




