Home>Highlight>Caddle sentenced to 24 years in murder-for-hire scheme

Sean Caddle. (Photo: Courtesy of PolitickerNJ).

Caddle sentenced to 24 years in murder-for-hire scheme

Former political consulant hired hitmen to kill Michael Galdieri

By David Wildstein, June 29 2023 3:15 pm

Former political consultant Sean Caddle was sentenced to 24 years in prison for hiring two hitmen to murder a business associate and friend brutally, Michael Galdieri.

The U.S. Attorney’s office had sought a prison term of no more than 15 years for Caddle in a heavily-redacted sentencing memorandum sent to U.S. District Court Judge John Michael Vazquez, who opted for a harsher sentence.  Caddle was immediately taken into custody.

Caddle admitted hiring two career criminals, George Bratsenis and Bomani Africa, in 2014 to fatally stab Galdieri in his Jersey City apartment and then set the apartment on fire.

Federal prosecutors identified Caddle’s motive as extortion, saying that Galdieri, who had a history of drug problems, had threatened to blackmail him over things he had seen on political campaigns they had been involved in.

As Galdieri stepped up his extortion, Caddle decided to have him killed.

“Sean Caddle unleashed two violent hitmen to stab Michael Galdieri to death and set fire to his apartment,” said U.S. Attorney Sellinger. “Despite being lifelong friends, Caddle paid to have Galdieri murdered because he thought that his own business interests were at risk. Today’s sentence is a just punishment for a heinous crime and provides some measure of justice for the victim and his family. I want to credit the dedicated agents of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the members of my Office who doggedly pursued this cold case murder investigation for years and have now brought to justice all three individuals responsible for the death of Michael Galdieri.”

The bizarre and tragic episode turned out to have significantly less drama than initially believed after some had touted conspiracy theories that sensationalized Caddle’s murder-for-hire scheme and suggested that Galdieri’s murder might have been connected to powerful New Jersey politicians.

His guilty plea, entered in January 2022, was followed by eighteen months of monitored home confinement, leading to speculation that he might have offered up information on a bigger fish.

But so far, Caddle’s cooperation with the U.S. Attorney’s office has netted just one small fish: Tony Teixeira, the former Elizabeth Democratic municipal chairman.

“Regardless of any dispute or argument a person has with someone, hiring hitmen to solve it is not only cold-hearted and despicable, but also against the law,” said James E. Dennehy, FBI Special Agent in Charge. “Caddle now faces justice for paying to having his former colleague and friend murdered. He will spend years in federal prison contemplating his actions, a small price to pay when another man lost his life.”

Caddle’s brother, who had been in prison with Bratsenis, introduced the two.  They met for dinner at Caddle’s home to discuss the plan.  Prosecutors have said Caddle knew that Bratsenis had committed a murder in 1984.

Vazquez sentenced Bratsenis to 16 years in prison, and Africa received 20 years.  Both are serving extended prison terms for other crimes.

Caddle, who had worked with former State Sen. Raymond Lesniak (D-Elizabeth) and ran several super PACs, admitted his role in the Galdieri murder on January 25.  He is currently under home detention on a $1 million unsecured bond at his residence in Sussex County.

Galdieri worked on political campaigns in Jersey City, including mayoral races for Louis Manzo and Bret Schundler and City Councilman Steve Lipski.  He served on the Jersey City Rent Leveling Board and worked for Manzo on his State Assembly staff.

His father won an unexpired term in the New Jersey State Senate in 1980, after the criminal conviction of State Sen. David Friedland (D-Jersey City) had created a vacancy.  Redistricting in 1981 left no path for him to remain in the Senate.  Galdieri’s grandfather represented Hudson County in the State Assembly in the 1930s.

In 2005, Michael Galdieri sought the Ward B seat on the Jersey City Council on a slate opposed to Mayor Jeremiah Healy.  The night before the election, he was arrested on drug and weapons charges and was sentenced to prison.  Mary Spinello defeated him.

Spread the news:

 RELATED ARTICLES