The New Jersey State Commission of Investigation is urging lawmakers to overhaul the state’s system for recording property transactions, warning that deed fraud and seller impersonation schemes are increasing while existing safeguards often do little more than alert victims after their property has already been transferred.
In a 56-page report submitted to Gov. Mikie Sherrill and the Legislature, the commission recommends stricter identity-verification requirements for real estate agents, notaries, attorneys and others involved in property conveyances. It also calls for enhanced property-alert systems, voluntary title freezes and expedited court proceedings to help victims recover homes and land before fraudulent transfers can be resold or mortgaged.
“Deed fraud is in the news,” the report begins, citing a 2024 FBI warning that fraudsters were stealing land “out from under” New Jersey property owners by impersonating them and recording deeds in new names.
The SCI’s investigation, which began in the fall of 2025, included more than 65 interviews with representatives of all 21 county clerks’ and prosecutors’ offices, as well as real estate agents, title professionals, law enforcement officials and victims.
The commission concluded that New Jersey property owners are “increasingly” being victimized, although the state lacks a uniform system for tracking the crimes.
The FBI identified approximately 135 reported incidents in New Jersey between 2020 and early March 2026. The cases were concentrated in several counties, including Sussex, Bergen, Cape May and Ocean.
That figure likely understates the scale of the problem, the report said. Victims may not report fraud because of embarrassment, because the matter is handled as a civil dispute, or because the crime is discovered years after the fraudulent transaction. Some attempted schemes are also stopped before a deed is recorded and never appear in official statistics.
An industry report cited by the SCI estimated that the true number of cases could be two to five times higher than reported figures.
Nationally, the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center recorded an increase in real-estate-related fraud complaints from 9,359 in 2024 to 12,368 in 2025. Reported losses rose from approximately $173.6 million to $275.1 million during the same period. Deed fraud is not tracked as a separate category, making it difficult to determine how much of the increase involves fraudulent property transfers.
The schemes generally begin with identity theft. A fraudster obtains publicly available information about a property and poses as the owner, often targeting vacant land, second homes, abandoned properties, rental homes, estate properties, or residences owned by elderly or absentee owners.
The perpetrator may list the property below market value to attract a quick cash buyer, insist on a remote closing, use a voice-over-internet phone number, provide suspicious identification, or demand that proceeds be wired to an account that does not match the purported seller’s identity.
Fraudulent notarizations are another frequent component. The report cites title-industry data showing that the most common notarization problems involved fake notary credentials or the unauthorized use of genuine credentials.
The pandemic accelerated the problem by normalizing remote and hybrid real estate transactions, the SCI said. The increased use of electronic signatures, remote closings, and online land-record databases has made it easier for fraudsters to impersonate property owners and submit documents without face-to-face contact.
The damage can extend beyond the legitimate property owner. An unsuspecting buyer may pay for a property that the seller did not own. Title companies, escrow agents, mortgage lenders and other parties can face significant financial losses and litigation.
New Jersey’s existing property-alert systems offer some protection, but the commission found that they are inconsistent and generally operate only after a transaction has been recorded. Nineteen of the state’s 21 counties have adopted some form of property-alert service, but statute does not require them, and they differ in how they operate.
The alerts can help an owner discover a fraudulent filing, but they do not prevent the deed from being recorded. Under current law, county clerks generally must record documents that meet facial requirements and are not authorized to fully investigate whether the person signing the deed is the rightful owner.
That leaves victims with the burden of filing a lawsuit to quiet title and undo the transaction. The report said such cases can take years, leaving victims in legal limbo and allowing a fraudulent grantee to attempt to sell or mortgage the property to an innocent third party.
The SCI’s principal recommendations are designed to intervene earlier.
The commission wants real estate licensees to verify a seller’s identity before accepting a listing. That could include requiring government-issued identification and sending written notice to the property owner at the address listed in municipal tax records.
The report also recommends additional safeguards for notarizations, including possible thumbprints for documents affecting real property, centralized electronic notary logs, stronger training and systems that alert notaries when their names or seals are used on recorded documents.
The commission further recommends identity verification for all property conveyances, rather than focusing solely on quitclaim deeds. Although quitclaim deeds appear frequently in reported fraud cases, the SCI said any type of deed, mortgage, or other conveyance can be fraudulently prepared and filed when the transaction takes place outside the oversight of a lender, title company, or attorney.
The most significant proposal would allow property owners to place a voluntary freeze on their titles. The concept would operate much like a credit freeze: no sale, mortgage or other transaction affecting the property could proceed until the owner affirmatively removed the freeze through multifactor authentication.
The report points to similar programs in counties in Kansas and Missouri, where homeowners can create a self-imposed lien or biometric title lock. Those systems generally require owners to appear in person to establish the freeze and again to lift it before selling or refinancing.
The SCI acknowledged that a New Jersey system would need exceptions for probate, foreclosure, tax sales, court orders, death, incapacity, and other transfers that occur by operation of law. It also would have to protect elderly owners and people who lack access to digital authentication systems.
As an alternative or supplement, the commission said lawmakers could establish a delay period during which a deed would be provisionally filed but would not have full legal effect. If the registered owner challenged the transaction as fraudulent, the deed would remain legally unresolved until a quiet-title action or another proceeding determined its validity.
The report cites Florida and Alabama as examples of states that have paired stronger identity requirements with expedited court procedures. The SCI recommends that New Jersey adopt a similar two-part strategy: prevent fraudulent transactions where possible and provide a fast way to reverse them when prevention fails.
Several New Jersey bills already address portions of the problem, including proposals involving affidavits of title, quitclaim-deed notifications, statewide property-alert services, stays in fraud-related possession cases and disclosure of limited liability company ownership. None had advanced significantly by the time the report was completed.
The commission said those proposals are constructive but insufficient on their own.
“The failure to act inevitably will lead to more harm for defrauded New Jersey property owners,” the report states.
The SCI urged lawmakers to develop a coordinated response before the problem grows further and before a national model law on deed fraud is completed. It said New Jersey has an opportunity to lead rather than wait for additional victims, lawsuits, and financial losses to expose the weaknesses in the current system.



