A Superior Court judge has ordered a full hand recount of ballots in South Toms River’s mayoral election, where incumbent Oscar Cradle defeated Gigi Esparza by a single vote, 441-440.
Judge Robert Brenner granted Esparza’s recount petition Thursday over Cradle’s objections; his attorney, Justin Lamb, argued that the narrow margin alone was insufficient grounds for a recount.
Attorneys for both candidates and the Ocean County Board of Elections are working on a timetable for the recount. With Thanksgiving approaching and county election officials planning absences, the process could stretch into December. That would leave little time for either candidate to challenge the recount results in Superior Court and pursue an appeal before South Toms River’s governing body reorganizes on January 1.
The recount will include all ballots cast in the borough’s three election districts.
There were also three write-in votes, two of them for Esparza, and 11 ballots that were rejected and not counted. Those ballots could become significant in a race decided by one vote, although the write-ins and rejected ballots are not necessarily votes that can be added to either candidate’s total.
Esparza must pay $75 for the recount, the statutory fee of $25 for each election district.
Deputy Attorney General Mark Gulbranson, representing the Ocean County Board of Elections, opposed her request to waive the fee, arguing that Esparza’s public-interest justification would apply to virtually every recount.
The county certified Cradle’s one-vote victory on Wednesday.
South Toms River has been through a lengthy election battle before, one that took more than sixteen months to resolve.
In 2020, Republican Sandford Ross and Democrat George Rutzler tied at 772 votes apiece for a Borough Council seat. Two mail-in ballots cast by elderly voters who had signed them were rejected, giving Rutzler a two-vote victory.
Rutzler took office, but Ross challenged the decision. Superior Court Judge Arnold Goldman reinstated the ballots in April 2021, restoring the tie and removing Rutzler from office.
The Ocean County Board of Elections appealed, delaying a special election until March 2022. Ross eventually defeated Rutzler, 250-142, in an election that cost taxpayers approximately $80,000.
Ross lost his council seat earlier this month as Democrats Jacqueline Burns and Christina Mertz captured both seats up for election, reducing the Republican majority on the six-member council to 4-2.
The mayoral recount now raises the possibility of another court battle in a borough where a disputed election has already removed a council member from office.